PERTH & KINROSS WIN THE NORTHERN DIVISION JAMBOREE

A very happy Perth and Kinross County Team
Photo courtesy of P&K

Perth & Kinross won the Northern Division Jamboree at Monifieth today. 

Over the three days they played some amazing golf to triumph over Angus, Aberdeenshire and Northern Counties. 

 The team will go on to play in the Scottish County Finals at Forres Golf Club from 27 - 29 August 2021.

CLICK HERE FOR ALL THE RESULTS -- COURTESY OF ABERDEENSHIRE

2021 County Championships update

With numerous County Championships having been played over the last month -- here is the current update of 2021 County Champions

Rachel Polson -- Aberdeenshire

ABERDEENSHIRE

Champion - Rachel Polson

Aberdeenshire Website

EAST LOTHIAN   

Champion -  Tara MacTaggart

East Lothian - Championship Report

FIFE 

Champion - Gillian Paton 

Fife County Website

LANARKSHIRE 

Champion - Susan Wood

Lanarkshire Website

MIDLOTHIAN 

Champion - Freya Constable 

Midlothian Website

PERTH AND KINROSS

Champion  - Megan Ashley  

Perth and Kinross Website

STIRLING AND CLACKMANNAN  

Champion - Linda Allan

Stirling and Clackmannan Website

Rachael Polson wins the Aberdeenshire Ladies Championship

Huge congratulations to Rachel Polson of Murcar Links who became our 2021 ALCGA County Champion when she won 4&2 against Robyn Fowlie of Forfar in a match that was fiercely contested by both players who played excellent golf.

To read the full report go to the Aberdeenshire LCGA Website

Zibby Brown is the new Aberdeenshire County Selector

Aberdeenshire Ladies' County Golf Association is delighted to announce that Zibby Brown (pictured) has accepted their invitation to be our County team selector.

Zibby is replacing Laura McLardy who stood down last year. It was disappointing for Laura to miss out on the opportunity to end her second term in the role with a successful Jamboree – and optimistically County Finals. 

She also lost out on the chance to learn more by working alongside Laura, benefitting from her substantial knowledge and experience of selecting, including when Aberdeenshire won the Scottish finals at Kilmacolm in 2018.

To read more go to the Aberdeenshire Ladies County Website

Big thank you from Aberdeenshire’s Ann Smart

A big thank you to all the lovely messages and cards I have received on the honorary membership at Banchory Golf Club. 

Golf has been a great part of my life. Offices held at club leading to national and county selection, junior county golf seeing a young Laura Murray and Michele Thomson progress through all the ranks and now really successful Professional golfers. 
Convincing Michele to give up the footie !  -- 

Then of course Aberdeenshire County Captain and that great Scottish Win with a great bunch of girls and not forgetting my back up team. 

To get honorary membership is the icing on the cake. 

There are a lot of famous names on that list and I’m very proud to be on it even though not for the same talent ! 

Banchory is a great club and the members make it. 

Thank you. 
Ann Smart

In case you missed the news -- READ FURTHER DOWN 

ANN SMART IS AWARDED HONORARY LIFE MEMBERSHIP BY BANCHORY GOLF CLUB

Ann Smart with her winning Aberdeenshire Team in 2018 at Kilmacolm
Click to enlarge

Banchory Golf Club is delighted to report that the Management Committee have recently recognised the significant contributions of  by Ann Smart and has awarded her Honorary Life Membership of the club. 

Ann retired from her role of Secretary at the end of the 2019 playing season and not only served the club loyally in her employment, but represented the club in numerous capacities including roles at county and national levels. 

Ann was also a past Management Committee member, a multiple Ladies Champion and Ladies Captain 2006 - 2007. As those that know Ann will attest it was not what she did for the club that is to her credit but the manner in which she did so, showing a love and enthusiasm for the game at all times.

Many congratulations Ann -- so very very well deserved 

As many will know from a previous post reported in  June - Click Here ---  Ann has been battling against lymphoma and is starting her second round of treatment tomorrow (27th July) -- Banchory's Morag Clapperton,  RLCGA Past captain June Lockhart and myself chat on zoom every Friday  and what an inspiration she is fighting this horrible disease. We all do have have great laughs with past stories on the golf course,  quizzes  and much more -- Good Luck Ann and hope to be back on the chat at the end of this week and get that game of golf eventually.  

DOWN MEM0RY LANE- LAURA SHARES A LOVELY MEMORY

CLICK TO ENLARGE

Aberdeenshire's Laura McLardy (Duff House Royal) shared a lovely memory on facebook 
She said "I think this makes me officially old. 25 years ago today that I got down to scratch- hard to believe it’s so long ago. One of my better golfing moments."

GET WELL MESSAGE FROM ABERDEENSHIRE CAPTAIN LORNA JOHNSON

Ann, June and Morag at the 2019 RLCGA Dinner

Your Webmaster has been keeping in touch with Past Aberdeenshire's Captain, Ann Smart, her good pal Morag Clapperton and Renfrewshire Past Captain June Lockhart -- We chat every Friday evening on "ZOOM" 

As Aberdeenshire's Captain Lorna Johnson said " For those who don' t know  - unfortunately Ann has been battling against lymphoma and I am very disappointed to tell you that her chemotherapy treatment to date has not been totally effective and, consequently, she has to have further treatment that will be specified soon."

"Given lockdown, social distancing, and isolation, Ann has faced an especially arduous time. Her attitude is always inspiring. I know that you will all join with me in sending her our very best wishes through the next stage of her journey to recovery."   --- READ MORE NEWS FROM THE ABERDEENSHIRE WEBSITE

2018 County Team Champions - Aberdeenshire

Ann of course was the Captain of the Winning 2018 Scottish County Team Championship in a close battle against Renfrewshire and everyone was delighted for Ann's team and their success that year - their last victory had been 1986  -- Read More

FOR FINAL DAY PHOTOS FROM KILMACOLM CLICK HERE FOR MEMORIES

Hopefully the next lot of treatment will be successful and you need to know Ann we are very much thinking about you, and hoping that you keep fighting this rotten disease Cx 

Carmen Griffiths wins the Aberdeenshire County Girls Championship

Carmen Griffiths and Rachal Mathieson

The Aberdeenshire County Girls  Championship was played in wet and windy conditions at Portlethen Golf Club on Sunday 20th October. 

The 2019 champion, winning narrowly (by a better inward half) with an 80 was Carmen Griffiths (Aboyne).

Runner up, and winner of the handicap championship was Rachel Mathieson (Hazlehead) with 80-5, net 75. 

Close behind was Robyn Fowlie (Edzell) with an 83-4, net 79.

Aboyne Award Honorary Membership to Kimberley Beveridge

Kimberley Beveridge with the Scottish Women’s Amateur Championship trophy and Club President Justin Grant 

 Press Release 28th October 2019 

At the season end prizegiving ceremony held at Aboyne Golf Club on Saturday night, the club awarded Kimberley Beveridge ‘Honorary Membership’ in recognition of her outstanding achievements in the Amateur Game. 

Making the award, Club President Justin Grant said “Kimberley has had a fantastic last few seasons culminating in her being crowned Scottish Women’s Amateur Champion at Barassie this year. She is also the current Aberdeenshire Ladies County Champion, having won this at Murcar a few weeks earlier. 

Justin went on, “A talented junior, Kimberley was a 3 times Aberdeenshire Girls Champion and represented Scotland Girls and Schools teams. Amongst other highlights Kimberley has regularly represented Aberdeenshire Ladies and helped them win the Team County Championship for the first time in 32 years in 2018. She also won the prestigious St Andrews Junior Ladies Open Championship in 2018. 

Kimberley won her first full international cap for Scotland in 2014 and her recent form led to ‘Scottish Golf’ selecting her to win her second cap representing her country in the R&A Women’s Home Internationals at Downfield, Dundee in August of this year.” 

Kimberley, aged 24, is a former pupil at Aboyne Academy who still lives in the village and works part time in the professional’s shop at the course. 

In her acceptance speech Kimberley said "It has been a tremendous season and I am overwhelmed that Aboyne Golf Club have seen fit to present me with such a prestigious accolade. The club and members have given me so much support and encouragement in recent years and I am very proud to have been awarded Honorary Membership of this fantastic club." 

Perth and Kinross County win the Northern Inter County Team Championships

Perth and Kinross County Team 

Northern Division Inter County Team Championship 2019 at Ballater Golf Club - Perth and Kinross are the winners

 CLICK HERE FOR ALL THE RESULTS

PERTH AND KINROSS COUNTY TEAM FOR JAMBOREE AT BALLATER

Ballater Golf Club

Four Counties will do battle at Ballater. They are Aberdeenshire, Angus, Northern Counties and Perth & Kinross. The winner will go on to play at the Scottish County Finals in September.

The team selected to represent Perth & Kinross this weekend is:

Perth & Kinross
Katy Alexander  (Blairgowrie)
Megan Ashley  (Strathmore)
Kirsty Brodie  (Strathmore)
Steph Crolla  (Muckhart)
Amy Mitchell  (Strathmore)
Isla Moncrieff  (Pitlochry)
Jen Saxton  (Muckhart)
Laura Walker  (Muckhart)

Reserve
Zoe Morton  (Auchterarder)

Order of Play
Day 1: Angus v Perth & Kinross - and - Northern v Aberdeenshire
Day 2: Perth & Kinross v Aberdeenshire - and - Northern v Angus
Day 3: Aberdeenshire v Angus - and - Northern v Perth & Kinross 

All spectators are welcome. 

Jane Yellowlees

Hon. Secretary
Perth & Kinross Ladies' County Golf Association

CLICK HERE FOR ABERDEENSHIRE NORTHERN AND ANGUS TEAMS

County Teams for the Northern Division Jamboree

COUNTY TEAMS for the Northern Division women's golf jamboree at Ballater Golf Club from June 15 to 17 are:

ABERDEENSHIRE

Kim Beveridge (Aboyne)

Carmen Griffiths (Aboyne)

Sammy Leslie (Murcar Links)

Jasmine MacKintosh (Hazlehead)

Donna Pocock (Murcar Links)

Megan Robb (Banchory)

Carol Wilson (Murcar Lnks)

Sheena Wood (Aberdeen Ladies)

Reserves:  

Rachel Polson (Murcar Links), Gillian MacKenzie (Banchory)

ANGUS 

Ailsa Summers

Claire Penman

Fiona GIlbert

Frances Millar

Jackie Brown

Jacqueline Cameron

Jane Grubb

Jess Meek

Reserves: Doreen Leask and Sarah Chapman

NORTHERN 

Ellie Docherty

Caitlin Boa

Claire Bannerman

Sandy Jackson

Mollie O’Brien

Steph Coverley

Cara Thompson

Meg SIevwright

KIMBERLEY BEVERIDGE WINS THE 2019 ABERDEENSHIRE WOMEN'S COUNTY CHAMPIONSHIP

Murcar Golf club Captain, Kimberley and  Sammy

ABERDEENSHIRE WOMEN'S COUNTY CHAMPIONSHIP
@ Murcar Links
SCRATCH
SEMI-FINALS
Kimberley Beveridge (Aboyne) bt Robyn Fowlie (Edzell) 7 and 5
Sammy Leslie (Murcar Links) bt Carol Wilson (Murcar Links) 5 and 3.'

FINAL: 
Kimberley Beveridge (Aboyne) bt  Sammy Leslie (Murcar Links) 1 hole

HANDICAP
FINAL
Jill Harrison (Cruden Bay) bt Julie Lees (Westhill) 6 and 4.

Who's who in this Karen Stalker picture:  Ann Smart (ALCGA Captain), Ronnie Brechin (Murcar Links Captain), Champion Kim Beveridge (Aboyne), Runner Up Sammy Leslie (Murcar Links), Semi Finalist Carol Wilson (Murcar Links), Handicap Champion Jill Harrison (Cruden Bay), Ros Dunsmuir (ALCGA President) and Leading Qualifier Fiona Campbell (McDonald Ellon).

CLICK HERE FOR PAST ABERDEENSHIRE NEWS

ABERDEENSHIRE WOMEN'S COUNTY CHAMPIONSHIP RESULTS

At Murcar Links

SCRATCH MATCH-PLAY
FIRST ROUND
F Campbell (McDonald Ellon) bt H Bycroft (Alford) 6 and 4.
R Fowlie (Edzell) bt M Adam (Hazlehead) 3 and 1.
D Pocock (Murcar Links) bt L Whyte (Aberdeen Ladies) 6 and 4.
K Beveridge (Aboyne) bt G Mackenzie (Banchory) 6 and 5.
C Wilson (Murcar Links) bt K Stalker (Cruden Bay) 2 and 1.
E Whyte (Aberdeen Ladies) bt R Mathieson (Hazlehead) 2 and 1.
S Leslie (Murcar Links) bt L Anderson (Duff House Royal) 8 and 6
C Griffiths (Aboyne) bt S Wood (Aberdeen Ladies) 6 and 4.

QUARTER-FINALS 
Fowlie bt Campbell at 19th
Beveridge bt Pocock 7 and 6
Wilson  bt  E Whyte at 19th
Leslie bt Griffiths at 19th

SUNDAY SEMI-FINALS
9.30 Fowlie v Beveridge
9.45 Wilson v Leslie

SCRATCH FINAL (Sunday, 2.15

HANDICAP
QUARTER-FINALS
J Lees (Westhill) (4) bt  V Neish (Murcar Links) (16) 3 and 2
 L Watson (Deeside) (16)  bt L Mutch (Meldrum House) (19) 6 and 4.
 J Harrison (Cruden Bay) (6) bt C Macdonald (Aberdeen Ladies) (13) 4 and 2.
M Finnie (Aberdeen Ladies) (10) bt E Gissing (Murcar Links) (11) 3 and 2
SEMI-FINALS
Lees (4) bt Watson (16) 3 and 2
Harrison (6) bt Finnie (10) 2 holes.

HANDICAP FINAL (Sunday, 10am)
Lees (4) v Harrison (6)

Fiona Campbell leads qualifiers for Aberdeenshire women's match-play at wintry Murcar Links

From the Scottish Golf View Website

By KAREN STALKER 

It was a very cold, blustery evening,  providing very testing conditions for the qualifying round of the Aberdeenshire women's county championship at Murcar Links.

Congratulations to leading qualifier Fiona Campbell (McDonald Ellon), pictured, with a excellent round of 77. She went out in 40 (+3) and back in 37 (+2). 

The par is 72, SSS 74 but the CSS was 77 reduction only.

The top 16 scratch players and the next eight handicap players play match-play tomorrow (Saturday), starting at 9.30.

LEADING SCRATCH SCORES
(CSS 77)
77 F Campbell (McDonald Ellon).
82 C Griffiths (Aboyne)
83 C Wilson (Murcar Links)
84 K Beveridge (Aboyne), D Pocock (Aboyne).
85 R Mathieson (Hazlehead), S Leslie (Murcar Links).
87 R Fowlie (Edzell)
88 M Adam (Hazlehead)
89 L Anderson (Duff House Royal)
91 E Whyte (Aberdeen Ladies)
92 L Whyte (Aberdeen Ladies), S Wood (Aberdeen Ladies).
92 H Bycroft (Alford).

SATURDAY MATCH-PLAY
FIRST ROUND
9.30 F Campbell v H Bycroft
9.40 M Adam v R Fowlie
9.50 D Pocock v L Whyte
10.0 G Mackenzie v K Beveridge
10.10 C Wilson v K Stalker
10.20 E Whyte v R Mathieson
10.30 S Leslie v L Anderson
10.40 S Wood v C Griffiths'
QUARTER-FINALS
14.30, 14.40, 14.50, 15.00

HANDICAP QUALIFIERS
80 V Neish (Murcar Links) (16)
86 M Finnie (Aberdeen Ladies) (10)
88 C Macdonald (Aberdeen Ladies) (13)
89 L Watson (Deeside) (16), L Mutch (Meldrum House) (19). J Harrison (Cruden Bay) (6)
90 E Gissing (Murcar Ladies) (11)
92 J Lees (Westhill) (4).
HANDICAP QUARTER-FINALS
10.50 V Neish v J Lees.
11.00 L Mutch v L Watson
11.10 C Macdonald v J Harrison
11.20 E Gissing v M Finnie.

   Winter weather in May for Aberdeenshire women's county championship
at Murcar Links. Pictures by Karen Stalker.

      

ABERDEENSHIRE FIXTURE LIST.

May 2: Open meeting, Aboyne​
 May 3-5: ALCGA County Championship, Murcar Links​
 May 9: Open meeting, Banchory​
 May 18: Open meeting, Fraserburgh​
 May 20: Watt Duffus Inter-Club Trophy, Inverurie

 June 13: Open meeting, Westhill   ​
 June 15-17: Northern Division Jamboree, Ballater
​ June 28: Open meeting, McDonald Ellon​

 July 1: Open meeting, Murcar Links​
 July 4: Open meeting, Kemnay​
 July 12: Tri-Am, Banchory​
 July 25: Open meeting, Cruden Bay​
 July 29: Open meeting, Deeside​

 August 2: Open meeting, Newmachar​
 August 5-6: Lyon Inter-Club Foursomes, Aboyne​
 August 19: Commonwealth Spoons, Duff House
 Royal​
 August 29: Open meeting, Peterculter

ABERDEENSHIRE COUNTY PRIZEGIVING

Some of the major prizewinners

ABERDEENSHIRE juniors had a great season this year.

 Carmen Griffiths (Aboyne) - Aberdeenshire County Champion , Rachel Mathieson (Hazlehead) and Robyn Fowlie (Edzell) are pictured in the centre of this Aberdeen Ladies County prizewinners presentation with their array of trophies.

Aberdeenshire has a great future with these girls.

Prizewinners -- Click to enlarge

ABERDEENSHIRE ARE THE 2018 COUNTY TEAM CHAMPIONS

Aberdeenshire - 2018 County Team Champions

Renfrewshire County are Runners Up

Aberdeenshire won the Scottish women's county championship for the first time since 1986 in a nail-biting finish to the three-day finals at Kilmacolm Golf Club today.

It couldn’t have been closer  with Aberdeenshire recording 15.5 points, pipping Renfrewshire by half a point, with Midlothian another half point behind on 14.5 points.

In the final day’s matches, Aberdeenshire came flying out of the blocks against Renfrewshire winning all of the morning foursomes to take a 3-0 lead into lunch.

In the afternoon singles matches, Sammy Leslie (Murcar Links) defeated Alyson McGinnigle (Cowglen) 3&2 and Kimberley Beveridge (Aboyne) overcame Donna Jackson (Troon Ladies) 4&3. 

The experienced Sheena Wood (Aberdeen Ladies) and Curtis Cup player Shannon McWilliam (Aboyne) both halved their matches against Gillian Kyle (East Renfrewshire) and Megan Briggs (Kilmacolm) while there were victories for Renfrewshire’s Eilidh Briggs (Kilmacolm)  and Jennifer Rankine to end the match 6-3. 

Match of the day was between Renfrewshire’s Jennifer Rankine (Haggs Castle) and Jasmine Mackintosh (Hazelhead) who were both round in 66  and Jennifer finishing birdie 2 and chipping in for a birdie  3 at the 18th to win the tie. In fact at the 12 th Hole they both nearly had holes in one to half the hole in 2 !!

Aberdeenshire last won the title in 1986 when Sheena Wood was in that team -- She has now been playing in the team for 35 years !!

Aberdeenshire v Renfrewshire Photographs 

MIDLOTHIAN  5  DUMFRIESSHIRE 4

Morning Foursomes : Midlothian 1.5 Dumfriesshire 1.5

Kate McIntosh and Wendy Nicholson lost to Corisande Lee and Jordan Graham 3&2
Karen Ferguson-Snedon and Caroline Steedman bt Katie Malcolm and Katie McCracken 3&2
Louise Fraser and Carys Irvine halved Mirren Fraser and Diane McDonald

Afernoon Singles: Midlothian 3.5 Dumfriesshire 2.5

Alison McBride lost to  Corisande Lee 3&1

Rachael Livingstone lost to Jordana Graham 3&2

Karen Ferguson- Sneddon w.o Mirren Fraser

Carys Irvine halved with Katie Malcolm

Caroline Steedman bt Latie McCracken 5&3

Louise Fraser bt Fiona Allison 2&1

RENFREWSHIRE 3 ABERDEENSHIRE 6

Morning Foursomes: Renfrewshire  0 Aberdeenshire 3

Eilidh Briggs and Jennifer Rankine lost to Shannon McWilliam and Jasmine McIntosh 4&3
Megan Briggs and Carol Whyte lost to  Sammy Leslie and Kimberly Beveridge 3&2
Donna Jackson and Liz Stewart lost to Sheena Wood and Carol Wilson 3&2

Afernoon Singles: Renfrewshire 3 Aberdeenshire  3 

Alyson McGinnigle lost to Sammy Leslie 3&2

Eilidh Briggs bt Carol Wilson 3&1

Gillian Kyle halved with Sheena Wood

Megan Briggs halved with Shannon McWilliam

Jennifer Rankine bt Jasmine MacKintosh 1 Hole

Donna Jackson lost to Kimberley Beveridge 4&3

HOW THEY FINISHED
                               P-W-D-L    F      A  Pts
Aberdeenshire  ....... 3-2-0-1  15.5-11.5  2
Renfrewshire .........  3-2-0-1  15  - 12     2
Midlothian .............  3-2-0-1  14.5-12.5  2
Dumfries-shire ....... 3-0-0-3     9 -  18    0

READ THE SCOTTISH GOLF REPORT FROM DAY 3 

SCOTTISH GOLF REPORTS FROM DAY 1 & DAY 2

 CLICK HERE FOR ALL THE RESULTS --

COUNTY FINALS AT KILMACOLM - DAY 2 - RENFREWSHIRE WIN AND MIDLOTHIAN STAGE A COMEBACK AGAINST ABERDEENSHIRE

Renfrewshire's Donna Jackson and Liz Stewart

SOME PHOTOS FROM TODAY

Renfrewshire are odds-on favourites to retain the Scottish Women's County Championship at Kilmacolm after beating Dumfries-shire 6.5-2.5 today (Saturday) while their main rivals, Aberdeenshire, leading by 2pt after the foursomes, nosedived in the singles and lost 5.5-3.5 to Midlothian. 

To win the title Aberdeenshire would need to win their final match on Sunday, against Renfrewshire, by a big-enough margin to cancel out the title-holder's commanding "goal difference" of 12-6 compared with Aberdeen's 9.5-8.5 

Renfrewshire's stalwarts Donna Jackson and Liz Stewart  won their foursomes match comfortably in the morning and both picked up a point each in the afternoon. County Champion Eilidh Briggs won all her matches today with Jennifer Rankine picking up a point and a half.

Aberdeenshire's collapse in the singles - which they lost 5-1 - started with a shock 6 and 5 defeat for Curtis Cup player Shannon McWilliam from Aboyne at the hands of Karen Ferguson-Snedden who was three up after 10 holes.


RENFREWSHIRE 6.5 DUMFRIESSHIRE 2.5 

Morning Foursomes : Renfrewshire 3 Dumfriesshire 0
Eilidh Briggs and Jennifer Rankine bt Coisande Lee and Jordan Graham 2 holes
Megan Briggs and Carol Whyte bt Mirren Fraser and Diane MacDonald 1 Hole
Donna Jackson and Liz Stewart bt Katie Malcolm and Fiona Allison 6&4

Afernoon Singles:Renfrewshire 3.5 Dumfriesshire 2.5

Megan Briggs lost to Corisande Lee 2&1

Eilidh Briggs bt Jordana Graham 4&3

Jennifer Rankine halved wih Mirren Fraser

Alyson McGinnigle lost to  Katie McCracken 1Hole

Liz Stewart bt Fiona Allison 2&1

Donna Jackson bt Katie Malcom 2&1


MIDLOTHIAN 5.5 ABERDEENSHIRE 3.5

Morning Foursomes: Midlothian 0.5 Aberdeenshire 2.5
Kate McIntosh and Wendy Nicholson lost to Shannon McWilliam and Jasmine Mackintosh 7&5
Alison McBride and Carys Irvine lost Kimberly Beveriddge and Samantha Leslie 4&3
Louise Fraser and Rachael Livingstone halved with Sheena Wood and Carol Wilson 

Afernoon Singles: Midlothian 5 Aberdeenshire 1
Karen Ferguson - Sneddon bt Shannon McWilliam 6&5
Wendy Nicholson bt Vikki Thom 4&3
Alison McBride halved with Jasmine Mackintosh
Caroline Steedman bt Sammy Leslie 2&1
Carys Irvine bt Sheena Wood 3&2
Rachael Livingstone halved with Kimberley Beveridge

Renfrewshire 2pts (12 games for 6 against)
Aberdeenshire 1 pt (9.5 games for 8.5 against)
Midlothian 1pt (9 games for 9 against)
Dumfriesshire 0 pts (5.5 games for 12.5 against)

FINAL MATCHES 
Midlothian v Dumfries-shire 
Renfrewshire v Aberdeenshire